Skip to main content

The Horror Protagonist

The core of the tragic character is, despite their hubris, rational. In fact, it is this rationality that allows the audience to empathize with their plight. If hardships befall a fool, or if the protagonist willingly walks into their own doom without forethought, the audience may cheer their dissolution, and will very likely be bored. The character's actions and motivations are understandable, and therein lies the pathos. If a character finds themselves in a horrible situation, even by their own hand, the audience must feel that they'd be in the same situation given the same circumstances.

The horror protagonist must be self-propelled towards their doom, and those choices must ring true. This is almost self-evident, but think to all of the cheap and lazy horror stories that depend on the main character's intense stupidity and stubborn refusal to acknowledge anything like danger. Without the protagonist's rationality (and note that I do not mean that each choice they make follows the rules of logic; the choices must simply follow from their understanding of the world), there is no tragedy. The horror movie becomes little more than victim porn, and while the imagery of victimization is powerful and visceral, it's fragile unto itself. Consider that if the character chooses a path that is explicit in it's danger or likely to end in the protagonist's death, they must have a powerful motivation to do so. Otherwise, the suspension of disbelief is ruined and the audience turns on the protagonist. The entirety of the Slasher genre is based around this phenomenon.

However, neither can the doom be secreted from the audience. If the protagonist is struck down by a random bullet, we may say it is horrifying, but we really mean it is shocking. Shock had a very short shelf life, and is only good for one use. The point of no return must be the most necessary action at the time-- and the audience must understand that action.

As a specific example, consider the British movie "The Descent". In it, a group of spelunkers head into a cave system where they are terrorized by the morlock-like creatures that live there. In the hands of a poor writer, this could be a disaster. Exploring an unknown cave is dangerous, and doing so without proper equipment is criminally stupid. But "The Descent" succeeds in placing the audience in the skins of the characters to such an extent that while we may wish they didn't engage in such a dangerous move. We know that circumstance has aligned against them, rather than them inviting disaster.

Many horror writers focus on the scenario above the characters, and to shoehorn the characters into that situation they force all manner of stupid choices down their throat. For example, in the remake of Texas Chainsaw Massacre, the heroine is confronted with a choice: flee down the deserted highway and hope for rescue, or run into the abandoned meat packing plant. Any sane person would find level ground, run their ass off, and put miles between the mutant family and themselves. Jessica Biel opts for the slaughterhouse, because the writer wanted a set piece there. It's lazy writing, and as a result, the audience turned against the hero.

Up Next: The Theory of Narrative Gestalt


Popular posts from this blog

The Theory of Narrative Gestalt

Story happens.

The human animal is a storytelling machine. We never need to be taught the basics of narrative, because the basis for all story is simple causality. Events that follow one another are likely linked, our brains dictate, and we scour the environment for clues to the nature of that link. If nature does not provide an obvious answer, we confabulate and confuse, projecting our intuitive understanding of human motivations upon the world. It is this inborn need that is the core of narrative.

We understand stories on a primal level; they trick our limbic system and beguile our amygdala. True, on the higher levels of thought we understand this is an illusion, but one we are willing to indulge in for the sake of a thrill; we aren't such slaves to our passions as to allow them unchecked reign. The methods of this manipulation have been codified, expanded upon, and undercut since the Classical period, but the core of story -- causality with meaning-- is maintained. A grea…

Societas Insomnia

After hunting around the internet for a few minutes, I found a few pictures from my time performing for the Portland performing arts troupe Societas Insomnia. It was a deeply disorganized group, with dozens of performers dropping out and being replaced, sound and lighting issues, and big egos getting stepped on constantly. But man oh man, do I enjoy performing.

The Postage Stamp Renaissance

This is the story of how a postage stamp, a rocket scientist, and a blind bluesman brought an obscure musical tradition of outer Mongolia to the world.

I'm sitting in a Portland, Oregon rock club. It's situated right smack in the middle of the downtown meat market. To the right of me is Voodoo Donuts. Gutter punks spange outside, grabbing a few bucks from the drunks attracted to the scent of bacon and glazing. To the left of me is a flophouse, the human overflow sleeping in the streets outside it. On a normal night, the club caters to bored frat boys and enterprising bank tellers, everyone dressed in their cleanest polo shirts, Axe so thick it smells like a Thai ladyboy exploded.

Tonight it's different. The club is filled with drifting incense. People crowd the stage, sitting on the floor indian style, necks aching to see the white robed performers. Passers by wander in, hoping for the usual drunken party, and stand struck dumb. The sta…